On My Block · Austin Politics

City HallSocial services

Social services reset: two surveys, pay-for-performance options and a rewritten anti-lobbying rule for nonprofits

Staff will brief two council committees Nov. 18 on surveys, contract types and ways to pay providers for results. The next day, the council takes up the mayor's rewrite of the no-lobbying rules.

Austin is redesigning how it pays nonprofits to run shelters, food programs and other social services. The newest details are in a presentation for the City Council's Audit and Finance Committee at 9:30 a.m. Wednesday, Nov. 18. The Economic Opportunity Committee is set to hear the same update at 11:30 a.m. that day.

Our October story covered the first briefing on the "reset" of the city's roughly $101 million social services portfolio, which aims to have new agreements in place in October 2027. Here is what's new.

Two surveys

Staff plan two surveys, built with the city's communications department:

  • one for current, former and would-be city-funded providers, on performance expectations, contracting and barriers;
  • one for residents, people with lived experience, advocates and frontline workers, on unmet needs, access problems and gaps by area.

Staff say they also will use an existing employee survey, vendor listening sessions from this year's budget and monthly meetings with One Voice, a coalition of nonprofits.

Contracts or grants

The presentation splits the work in two. Contracts are for services the city must provide, such as running a city-owned shelter or court interpretation. Grants are for services the city chooses to provide, such as food distribution or outreach to people experiencing homelessness.

Most current agreements simply reimburse providers' costs. The options listed for tying money to results:

  • bonus payments for beating targets, which Austin tried with rapid rehousing in 2022-23 and which paid bonuses to six providers;
  • renewals only for providers who meet targets;
  • paying per item delivered, such as each meal served, instead of reimbursing operating costs.

Other policy questions on the list include how much of a program or a whole organization the city should fund and what overhead rates to allow.

How the city buys these services

The city last sought proposals for its whole social services portfolio in 2014, a $13.8 million round, according to the presentation. Other rounds have covered one issue area, such as early childhood, or new money, such as aging services. The presentation does not say which approach the city will use next. Staff say working groups finish by the end of December, the procurement process starts in early 2027, and all new agreements take effect in the 2028 budget year, which starts Oct. 1, 2027.

The anti-lobbying change, Nov. 19

The council votes the next day on two items from Mayor Kirk Watson, co-sponsored by Mayor Pro Tem José "Chito" Vela and Council Members Ryan Alter and Vanessa Fuentes:

  • A resolution putting social services contracts and grants under the city's standard procurement and grant rules, with training and a point of contact for providers.
  • An ordinance that removes social services from the exemptions in the city's anti-lobbying law. The draft also changes the law for every city solicitation:

- The no-lobbying period would start when responses are due, not when a solicitation is published. - It would end when the council approves or declines the last contract. Now it can run until the contract is signed or 60 days after council approval. - Appeals of a disqualification would go through the purchasing office's protest process, not a panel of the Ethics Review Commission. - A new exception allows talks between officials and providers about social services generally and about matters outside an active solicitation.

What our records add

Four resolutions drive the reset. The presentation cites them. The first, adopted 11-0 as amended on Feb. 26, called for a rubric to decide which contracts to fully fund, partly fund or end. It came from the Public Health Committee. The newest, adopted Oct. 22, asks for outcomes by district or ZIP code.

Watson's reasoning. At the Oct. 21 committee meeting, he said the city spends more than $100 million on nonprofit contracts that the lobbying rule does not cover. "We ought to do that," he said.

The scoring rubric. The presentation lists five factors worth 75 points: community need (25), the trend in that need (15), the city's strategic role (15), investment efficiency (10) and council and community direction (10).