Audit and Finance Committee

Wednesday, September 17, 2025, 9:30 a.m. (Austin time), Austin City Hall, 301 W 2nd St, Austin, TX 78701

Committee: Audit and Finance Committee

Video of the meeting

On the agenda

Documents

Summary

The Audit and Finance Committee met on September 17, 2025, chaired by Vice Chair Ryan Alter in Mayor Watson's absence. The committee heard one public comment requesting an audit of outdoor music venue permits. They approved minutes, adopted bylaws for the Community Police Review Commission and amendments for the LGBTQ Quality of Life Commission. They received a briefing on the lobbyist compliance audit, which found that 40% of city departments do not provide a method for lobbyists to report scheduled meetings and that current code limits transparency. They received an audit of Austin Resource Recovery's recycling and composting education efforts, which found inconsistent prioritization of educational efforts and inconsistent messaging. Finally, they received an update on city redevelopment projects including Colony Park, St. John, Grove Riverside, and Health South.

Transcript

0:03 Hey everybody. I am vice chair Ryan al Alter.

0:10 The Mayor is out of town.

0:11 So I am quarterbacking our meeting today for better or for worse.

0:17 Um, we are here at City Hall chambers on Wednesday, September 17th.

0:21 It is 9 32. Uh, we are 3 0 1 west second street in Austin, texas.

0:28 Um, before we begin, do we have any public speakers today?

0:33 Yes, we have one.

0:34 Alright, well, we'll begin with public speakers and then we'll work our way through the agenda if we

0:39 can have Ryan saunders.

1:04 Hello. Good morning. Ready for me to start?

1:07 Alright. Uh, so I'm here to request, um, an audit of the way the, uh, outdoor music venue

1:14 permits, which are related to, uh, sound for bars, music's, restaurants, venues, and neighborhoods.

1:20 Um, as you can see, the second largest number of 3 1 1 complaints in the city, uh, through August

1:26 of this year of 16,734 related to non-emergency noise and alarm.

1:32 If you could slides or what.

1:35 Thank you. Um, so essentially the things I wanna talk about is just what determines who gets an

1:43 omv permit, why it's required difference between dbc and dba indoor and outdoor standards, um, and then a

1:50 pd versus code enforcement.

1:52 Uh, so brian block has been the person in charge of doing these permits for the last several

1:57 years. They did change the department recently to arts, culture, music and entertainment, but brian has self-titled himself

2:04 the nightlife Mayor, and he has also now parlayed that into a consulting company while also working full-time

2:10 for the city. Um, and he's traveling to, uh, do this work.

2:16 While we're seeing that his work here in Austin is causing problems for our quality of life, and

2:20 I feel like he should be focusing more on what's happening in our city.

2:24 Uh, an outdoor venue states at a commercial establishment, uh, where it's fully, not fully enclosed by permanent

2:30 solid walls. And then it also further says, any commercial property where sound equipment is used to amplified

2:36 sound. Um, and then you see below that there's different standards for short-term rentals, residential to residential food

2:43 trucks, bars, restaurants, coffee shops, um, the gray area of indoor and outdoor.

2:48 If you have a garage door that's not a permanent wall, if you leave your front door open,

2:52 that's not a permanent wall if you leave your window open, that's not for fully closed permanent walls

2:57 yet. Those venues are not counted as outdoor music venue permits.

3:00 Um, you can see also that there's different standards.

3:04 A restaurant's supposed to be 70 dba, but then this one's allowed a 80 dbc, which base is

3:09 more disruptive, and this is in a neighborhood.

3:11 And then the next one is in an entertainment district.

3:14 And their dbc for base is lower than the one that's in a residential neighborhood and they're in

3:19 an entertainment district. Um, certain bars and venues are not even allowed to have omv because they're within

3:25 a hundred feet of a residence, but they're actually less regulated when they don't have an omv.

3:29 And it also makes them be under the enforcement of a pd rather than code enforcement, which wastes

3:33 resources. Um, also omv puts time limits, whereas a venues within a hundred feet, they don't have to

3:39 have an omv. They'll have loud music at higher levels than omv permitted venues till 2:00 am rather than

3:45 the lower restrictions. Uh, this one is on rainy street, has the same garage doors, open garage doors,

3:53 um, or to the next one as this one, which is in a residential neighborhood.

3:56 The one on rainy street has an omv.

3:58 They supposedly opted in drinks, has been determined to not be an outdoor music venue applicant.

4:09 Thank you. Chair. Yes, I was gonna ask if you could email your presentation to us, that'd be

4:14 helpful. Absolutely. Thank you.

4:15 Yeah, thank you for making the time today.

4:16 Thank you so much.

4:18 All right, with that we will move to item number one, which is approval of the minutes.

4:22 Can I get a motion?

4:23 I have motion by, uh, councilor Fuentes, seconded by Council Member uchin.

4:28 Uh, that objection. The minutes are adopted.

4:33 Uh, and I actually forgot to announce we have Council Member Fuentes, Vela and uchin here for the

4:40 meeting for whoever, whomever is taking the minutes.

4:44 Alright, item number two, uh, discussion and possible action on proposed bylaws for the community police review commission

4:52 and proposed bylaw amendments for the commission on aging and the l-g-b-t-q life advisory commission.

4:59 And I believe stephanie hall kick us off.

5:01 Yes. Good morning. Stephanie hall, assistant city clerk.

5:03 I have two bylaw amendments.

5:05 Well, one brand new bylaws from the community police review commission and an amendment to present to you.

5:11 The first is the lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer quality of life commission.

5:17 They would like to add the office of secretary to their commission.

5:21 And so that will be editing article four officers edit sections a, b, and c.

5:26 And they're also just making a cleanup edit in article seven meetings l to update that their staffing

5:33 department is now the office of city clerk, which has been true for some time.

5:37 Um, their justification for this is a sec secretary will improve coordination between the full commission and allow

5:41 well leadership to focus on facilitation staff has no issue with this amendment.

5:46 The second item I have for you are new bylaws from the community police review commission.

5:51 They are just adopting the standard template, filling in where it's applicable for them.

5:56 And it's just, just again, to establish their initial bylaws.

5:58 Staff fully supports this, these new bylaw limits.

6:02 Any questions? Councilor bayla?

6:05 No, just, uh, uh, move, uh, approval.

6:07 Oh, I do have a, a question as it relates to the community police review commission.

6:13 I certainly, um, understand, you know, that's, it's taken a while to get them spun up and, uh,

6:21 I believe the, um, public safety commission has had a discussion about this.

6:28 And I'm trying to remember if they actually made a formal recommendation or if it was just discussed,

6:34 but moving the cprc out from under the opo and into the clerk's purview, just like other commissions,

6:44 I was curious if that's something that y'all have had discussions about or, or your thoughts on that.

6:49 I do. I am aware of the poli the public safety commission.

6:54 I don't know. You're right.

6:55 I'm not sure if they actually adopted a formal recommendation.

6:57 I know they were talking about that, so I have seen and heard that.

7:00 I haven't had any other discussions with the commission or anyone else about that yet.

7:08 What is the status of the setting up the cprc?

7:12 They are, they're, as far as I know, they're fully set up right now and they are meeting,

7:16 this was just to formalize their bylaws so they have something in place.

7:20 Um, that's pretty much the extent that I know.

7:23 I I do know they have contact with the law department.

7:25 I do know obo is staffing them.

7:27 We have trained their staff liaisons, but they have additional training requirements that were outlined in the ordinance

7:34 that are more so than other boards and commissions.

7:36 So I'm looking at, I was able to find the recommendation what they, what the public safety commission

7:42 has asked for to this point is assignment of a staff liaison from the clerk's office to the

7:48 community police review commission.

7:50 Um, they cite the strain on opo having limited resources.

7:57 What would that look like if y'all, y'all liaise between commissions and other departments?

8:04 Like it's not always just a liaison between yourself and a, a commission?

8:10 If I understand your question correctly, we do.

8:12 So we do have three positions in our office that are actually now the liaisons for several.

8:17 It's mostly quality of life commissions.

8:19 We do actually liaise the public safety commission.

8:22 So I have three positions that do that.

8:24 All the other boards and commissions, we are kind of the middle between those staff liaisons and other

8:29 departments and council. So we do kind of interact with all of them, but we do have a

8:34 direct staffing relationship with about, I think it's 15 bodies.

8:40 Okay. All right. Well, I I think this is just something we should keep an eye on.

8:44 Yes. Council Member Fuentes, thank you for surfacing that recommendation.

8:48 Vice chair. Uh, certainly I am also concerned about staffing constraints within the opo office.

8:54 I know that they were supposed to attend a town hall that I had, uh, scheduled and ended

8:59 up canceling, I think pretty much last minute due to staffing constraints.

9:02 So I do worry about their ability to appropriately staff a very important commission such as the community

9:09 advisory board on safety.

9:11 Yeah. Well, I will, I I think we, we can talk more offline and, and also just better

9:16 understand if there are constraints.

9:18 'Cause we want the community community police review commission to be successful and, and have the resources they

9:25 need. So appreciate, uh, your work here.

9:27 And then we have a, a motion on the floor from Council Member vala to, uh, approve this

9:31 item. Is there a second?

9:32 Second by councillor Fuentes.

9:35 Uh, if there are no objections, I see none.

9:38 This will be, uh, approved.

9:41 Alright, now onto item number three.

9:44 This is a briefing on the audit of lobbyist compliance with city code and mateo.

9:55 Alright, mateo macias from the auditor's office and, and just for, uh, awareness, uh, erica brady, who is

10:05 our clerk, is, uh, off doing some required work in hayes county related to ballot certification or ballot,

10:13 something. Um, and if her office is here, if there are any questions on this, uh, her office

10:18 will take those questions and get us answers in the memo or some other, um, way to distribute

10:24 that. So with that, I turn it over to you.

10:28 Thank you. Council Member.

10:29 Hello, council members, my name is matto macias and I'm the law auditor in charge of this, this

10:34 year's edition of the lobbyist compliance audit.

10:37 The little context lobbying is when an individual seeks to influence the policy decision making of city officials.

10:46 Our office has conducted a few of these audits in the past, most recently in 2022 and 2019,

10:53 and we noted a few issues with transparency and accountability.

10:56 Pardon? Accessibility in response, the lobbyist meeting requirements and review by the city auditor sections were adjusted and

11:03 clarified. And the city and now city code directs our office to review information related to lobbyist meetings

11:09 for compliance. And that leads us to our first finding.

11:13 And this deals directly with the duties set out by city code in relation to lobbyist provisions.

11:18 And it reads, some city departments do not provide a reasonable way to record information from lobbyists as

11:24 required by city code.

11:27 All city departments and offices are required to provide, provide a method for lobbyists to report about scheduled

11:34 meetings. And in order to assess this requirement for compliance, our office conducted, conducted a survey and sent

11:42 it out to all city, city departments and offices, asking them if they do provide this method.

11:48 About 60% of them said yes that they do, and about 40% said that they, they do not.

11:54 And I think it's important to note that all City Council members' offices complied with this requirement, um,

11:59 as well as the city manager's office.

12:03 This, this section of city code also requires lobbyists to report information about scheduled meetings with city officials.

12:10 This physical signin sheet here that you see on the right was the most common form of method

12:15 provided by offices and departments.

12:17 However, it does not require all of the, it does not capture all of the necessary information needed

12:23 for office to conduct compliance as set out by city code.

12:28 This additionally, this physical sign-in sheet May not be complete or legible when it is filled out.

12:34 And of course, a physical sign-in sheet does not suffice for virtual meetings.

12:39 Um, and that leads us to our second finding, which addresses the more higher level inherent issues with

12:46 transparency and accessibility in this section of code.

12:50 And it reads current city code lobbying provisions, limit reporting, and make transparency hard to achieve.

12:56 And so we looked at a couple of our peer cities, dallas, el paso, and san antonio to

13:01 get a lay of the landscape, if you will, and we noticed a couple of differences between their

13:06 city code lobbying provisions and our own.