Public Safety Committee

Tuesday, May 12, 2026, 9 a.m. (Austin time), Austin City Hall

Committee: Public Safety Committee

Video of the meeting

Documents

Summary

The Public Safety Committee met on May 12, 2026, and postponed Item 3 (a briefing on Class C warrants, court notices, and failure-to-appear rates) to June 1 because staff could not present. The committee heard from four public speakers, all urging action on moving 9-1-1 and emergency communications out of the Austin Police Department and criticizing delays in the strategic plan and cost estimates directed by Resolution 2025-08813-018. Staff from the Assistant City Manager's office, Austin Police, Austin Fire, Austin Travis County EMS, and Labor Relations presented an update on the joint emergency communications initiative, noting a consultant (Mission Critical Partners) is still in the analysis phase and recommending a phased approach; council members pressed for the overdue strategic plan and cost analysis. The committee also received a briefing on park safety, covering park rangers, police response data, a parks security audit, mounted-unit patrols, and potential technology such as drones and security cameras. No votes were taken.

Transcript

0:02 I will call the public safety committee meeting to order.

0:04 It is May 12th, 2026 at 9:00 am this is a meeting of the public safety committee.

0:10 We are at City Hall, located at 3 0 1 west second street in Austin, texas.

0:14 And we have a quorum present vice chair lane Council Member Siegel and Council Member uchin.

0:18 Uh, colleagues, before we move forward with the public communication, I wanna share that we are postponing.

0:22 Item number three, the briefing on class c warrants, court notices and failure to appear.

0:26 Rates to the June 1st meeting.

0:29 Uh, the appropriate staff is unbe, unable to present today and requested a, uh, postponement.

0:34 And with that we will go to public communication.

0:39 We have five speakers, starting with peter hunt, mary elizabeth, kathy mitchell.

1:00 Good morning chair council members.

1:02 My name is peter hunt.

1:03 I'm a resident of district 10.

1:05 Uh, and I wanna speak a little bit about the, uh, resolution on which you're gonna hear a

1:10 briefing on for item number one.

1:12 This idea to establish a joint consolidated emergency response department, um, is good.

1:18 The reasoning behind it goes back over a decade, uh, but there have been some persistent obstacles to

1:23 actually establishing it in the last couple years.

1:26 And I wanna speak, you're gonna hear I think, probably about some of the, uh, more specific good

1:29 reasoning behind establishing this.

1:31 But I wanna talk a little bit about the context.

1:34 One of those contextual obstacles has been, uh, state law and the police budget.

1:38 Now, currently, because the 9 1 1 emergency response department is part of the police budget, moving out or making

1:45 a consolidated, uh, department would involve a technical reduction of apds budget, which runs a foul of, uh,

1:52 senate bill four from a couple years ago.

1:55 Um, last year would've been a great time to make this particular move.

2:00 The 2024 police agreement had locked in 8% raises for officers, which meant that the city was obligated

2:08 to increase the police budget in one place, and therefore, uh, reduction in another would've been a great

2:12 time to do it.

2:13 So it made good technical sense.

2:16 Uh, however, I think that there was some good wisdom behind counsel approving the resolution at that time

2:22 in August, authored by Council Member lane directing staff to perform an evaluation of what this move would

2:28 entail. Looking at costs consulting with community members, um, performing sort of a strategic analysis of what that

2:35 would look like. Unfortunately, uh, staff was directed to have that done by December 9th.

2:42 And from what I can tell in the backup of this meeting and what I see coming up

2:46 for the presentation, that hasn't really happened, um, we're six months past that deadline at this point.

2:52 And, uh, that assessment of technical costs, operational feasibility, uh, implementation, timelines and evidence crucially, of consulting with

3:01 external partners such as employee unions or community groups, um, I see don't, I don't see evidence of

3:08 that right now. Um, and I don't think it's appropriate for the city to continue dragging its heels

3:13 on what is going to be a good and sensible administrative adjustment to how 9 1 1 emergency response is

3:20 handled. And this year is also a year to do it.

3:23 Officers once again have locked in pay raises that would offset the cost, the technical cost of moving

3:30 the, uh, response out of the a pd budget, which means that there would not be any running

3:36 to file of state law.

3:38 And now's the time to do it.

3:39 So my request for, uh, members of this committee and for council as a whole, um, would be

3:45 to have this as an item in the budget for this year, looking ahead to July and August

3:50 to establish the joint consolidated, uh, 9 1 1 response department.

3:53 Thank you for your time.

4:03 Good morning. My name's mary elizabeth, and I'm for moving the nine one one call center out of a pd.

4:15 Moving 9 1 1 into an independent emergency communications department will help ensure that the people in crisis receive the

4:23 right response the first time.

4:27 Dispatch determines outcomes when the system defaults to sending armed officers to health crises.

4:34 The risk of escalation and violence increases.

4:38 Austin's audit shows that the system is failing.

4:42 The city of austin's audit of police responses to mental health incidents found that people in mental health

4:49 crises in Austin face a higher risk of fatal police encounters than incomparable cities.

4:57 Austin police department policies related to mental health, mental health incidents were less specific than national best practices.

5:07 Training and messages messaging around deescalation were inconsistent.

5:12 Police were often dispatched to calls that were non-criminal and better suited to health pro to health professionals.

5:22 This means that the current system structurally relies too much on police, on police for behavioral health emergencies.

5:35 Moving 9 1 1 out out from a pd would improve public safety.

5:41 It would standardize call triage protocols for mental health crises, making them more explicit, more specific to know

5:50 who to call out.

5:52 It would improve routing to mental health responders and ems reduce unnecessary armed responses.

6:00 Improve coordination between police, fire ems and civilian response teams, and explore better integration between 9 1 1 and 3 1 1

6:11 for non-emergency responses for non-emergency issues,

6:21 moving it out of a pd would support first responders would not eliminate police response where that is

6:30 necessary. It protects their capacity, respond to the calls they're needed for a pd has a longstanding cap.

6:42 A pd has a longstanding capacity issue.

6:46 Slow response to calls, staffing shortages.

6:50 Missed response goals. On average in 2025, a pd officers took over 45 minutes to respond to 9 1 1

7:03 calls. Thank you.

7:17 Good morning. I haven't been here in a good long while, and I hope y'all are watching all

7:22 my lovely baby pictures that I've been posting on facebook.

7:26 'Cause I think I have the cutest grandbaby.

7:29 Um, I'm here today first to remind you that this is a thing that the community has been

7:35 asking for for a very long time.

7:37 So I'm gonna be officially representing the people who have been thinking about this for a decade.

7:43 Um, it is really great that after last budget cycle, you all directed the city to do a

7:50 planning process. And it's very disappointing that that planning process doesn't appear to be what actually has happened.

7:58 Um, and I would say that the piece that I bring to this conversation, I pulled the 4 million

8:06 nine one one call records that are now posted on the open data portal, um, last night just to kind

8:16 of poke around and I could do a whole lengthy presentation on what is in this data.

8:24 But what I will tell you is that this data is not managing what we know about the

8:33 outcomes of the calls that people make to 9 1 1 and whether they got the right response.

8:41 That is not what this data does.

8:43 This data is a police management tool, police time management tool, and it is underutilized.

8:51 And I have always said that.

8:53 Uh, but what it does not, not do is what I'm hoping we are moving towards, which is

8:59 managing all of our emergency response system for the benefit of those who call and need help from

9:08 the city. So that means that when we have management in place that is serving and dispatching and

9:18 serving all of Austin and serving all of our people, uh, no matter what it is that our

9:25 people are calling for and needing that we will have better data because it's no longer going to

9:33 be about how many police units did we send and how long did they spend there, and were

9:39 they there on their own recognizance or did someone actually call and ask them to come and, and

9:46 on and on, right?

9:47 Those are all important questions for police, but they are not telling us whether the person on the

9:54 other end of the call got what they needed.

9:58 And you particularly see this with the mental health flag calls, and I will have a lot to

10:05 say about that after I've been able to sit down and kind of, you know, saturate myself in

10:11 the data. Uh, but I think for right now, I wanna just remind you that we added the

10:20 nine. Well you all remember mental health calls, <laugh>, thank you.

10:27 Thank you kathy for being here with us.

10:28 And, uh, thank you for the baby pictures also.

10:30 We've been enjoying them.

10:34 Last two speakers, savannah lee and felicia ross.

10:56 Good morning council members.

10:57 Uh, my name is savannah lee.

10:59 I'm here with equity action and I'm a resident of district one.

11:02 I'm here today in support of creating a joint emergency communications department and ensuring that this work is

11:07 funded in the 26 27 budget.

11:10 I wanna start by addressing the presentation today.

11:13 I was disappointed when I saw that there was no actual strategic plan or cost estimate as directed

11:18 by Council Member lane's resolution.

11:20 When we've waited several months past the deadline set out by council, community members expect a robust plan

11:25 that effectively informs us and council alike on the joint communications department itself.

11:31 This proposal is a common sense modern modernization effort that will help Austin send the right response the

11:36 first time. Dispatch determines outcomes.

11:39 The decisions made in the first moments of a nine one one call shape everything.

11:42 It follows whether resources are used efficiently, whether situations escalate, and whether people receive the kind of help

11:47 that they actually need.

11:49 The way dispatch currently operates means law enforcement is often the default response response, even for situations that

11:54 are primarily behavioral health or non-criminal in nature.

11:57 We've heard from community members that unless callers use very specific language, mental health calls are unlikely to

12:02 be routed to the most appropriate crisis response teams.

12:05 That's not an efficient system, and it's not a system designed around accuracy.

12:09 Austin's owned own audit found that police were frequently dispatched to non-criminal mental health calls better suited for

12:14 healthcare professionals. At the same time, cities like san francisco have shown that when dispatch systems are designed

12:20 to support civilian crisis teams, the vast majority of those calls can be resolved safely without police involvement.

12:25 While connecting people to care this proposal would improve.

12:29 Coordinate coordination across departments, standardized call triage protocols, improve routing to mental health responders in ems and reduce

12:36 unnecessary deployments. It would also support a pd capacity, an issue the department has continued to struggle with

12:42 by ensuring that officers are responding to calls where they're actually needed.

12:45 Importantly, this also also advance advances the goals of the safe to call resolution passed by council.

12:50 Emergency systems only work when people trust them enough to use them.

12:54 And more consistent training and appropriate responses will help to build that trust.

12:59 Ultimately, this is about creating a system that works better for everyone, residents, first responders, and people in

13:04 crisis alike. Thank you

13:10 as all speakers. Yes, sir.

13:13 Thank you. Uh, colleagues will now move on to item number one.

13:16 Uh, it's an update on the reso on resolution 2 0 2 5 0 8 8 1 3 dash 0 1 8 regarding the establishment of a joint

13:24 communications department. Combining the functions of 9 1 1 and emergency dispatch.

13:28 Uh, we have assistant city manager batista with us chief davis, chief baker chief.

13:33 Wait, I didn't see.

13:34 Oh, there's chief baker, chief lucker, uh, james stoner and roxanna stevens.

13:40 Welcome. Good morning council members.

13:44 Um, I'm ramon batista, a cm over republic safety.

13:47 I wanna begin with a brief history of the ctec slide.

13:53 Brief history of ctec, the combined transportation emergency and communication center.

13:58 Ctec manages critical communications for police, fire, uh, ems, travis county, t tech stock and capital metro.

14:06 Um, they support emergency response, traffic management and regional disaster readiness.

14:12 Um, as you can see, ctech started in 2003 with a professional staff civilian director of communications.

14:20 Um, since 2015, a pd has managed, um, the center's dispatch and coordination systems.

14:26 And during that time, Austin and our region have successfully responded to numerous natural and manmade disasters.

14:32 Today's discussion continues the joint emergency communications initiative as directed by council.