On My Block · Austin Politics

City HallAudits

Austin gives out more city credit cards than other big Texas cities, and a third of sampled purchases lacked clear records, audit finds

City staff spent almost $45 million on 1,571 cards last year. The City Auditor's draft report, set for the Audit and Finance Committee on Nov. 18, found 27% of cards were used less than once a month.

City of Austin employees spent almost $45 million on 1,571 city credit cards in the 2025 budget year, more cards and more spending than in Dallas, El Paso, Fort Worth, Houston or San Antonio. That's according to a draft report from the City Auditor's Office posted for the City Council's Audit and Finance Committee meeting on Wednesday, Nov. 18.

The auditors found that Austin does not regularly check whether employees still need their cards, trains cardholders once and never again, and often approves purchases without records showing what was bought or why. "These conditions increase the risk of fraud, misuse, and unnecessary spending," the report says.

The figures leave out Austin Energy. Its 237 cards, with about $10 million in spending, were managed separately last year and are now moving under the city's finance department, according to the report. Another 137 cards tied to a vendor or category, such as a phone company, accounted for about $32 million.

Austin next to its peers

| City | Individual cards | Staff per card | Spent per card | |---|---|---|---| | Austin | 1,571 | about 10 | about $28,400 | | El Paso | 449 | about 16 | about $6,500 | | Fort Worth | 436 | about 18 | about $23,200 | | Houston | 867 | about 26 | not collected | | Dallas | 475 | about 32 | about $17,600 | | San Antonio | 370 | about 37 | not collected |

Measured against the size of each workforce, Austin has more than three times as many cards as Dallas and almost four times as many as San Antonio. City staff told auditors they like cards because they are faster than other ways of buying. The city also earned about $1.2 million in rebates.

What the auditors found

  • Cards sit unused. 419 cards, or 27%, were used less than once a month. 159 were used less than four times all year. Three of the five peer cities review or shut off inactive cards; Austin does not.
  • One-time training. Every peer city requires refresher training; Austin requires only an initial course, which auditors said focuses on the software. In a survey, 37% of card users (285 of 769) said they did not remember the training or did not find it helpful.
  • Thin records. In a sample of 120 purchases from four departments, 35% had no clear business reason, 21% did not clearly say what was bought, and 32% did not fully match the receipt. Examples include "PDC Coffee Supplies" for $1,521 and "out on leave" for $285.
  • Miscoded buys. A step stool, a medical journal subscription and "Chat GPT" were each filed under "clothing/clothing material."
  • Heavy loads, light review. One department accountant approved as many as 7,381 transactions in a year, and 4,541 purchases skipped the supervisor's review. Auditors said that can leave a single real check.
  • No one looks at the whole picture. The city spent about $863,000 on tolls by card, 65% of it in two departments, neither of which had studied whether that made sense.

The report notes the City Auditor's Integrity Unit has published several investigations of card misuse since 2020, including one in which an employee bought at least $1.3 million in goods for personal use.

The city's response

The director of Austin Financial Services agreed with every recommendation. The department plans an annual review of all cards with written rules for when to cancel them, a new initial course plus a mandatory yearly refresher, and stronger rules for documenting purchases. Its target date for the card review and training is October 2027. Auditors noted the city plans to start posting card transaction data publicly later this year.

What our records add

More audits coming. The council is scheduled to adopt the auditor's 2027 audit plan on Nov. 19, after this committee advanced it without objection on Oct. 21. It adds 10 audits, including AI governance and facilities management; our story lists them.

Same meeting, second audit. The committee will also hear an audit of civilian staffing in the police, fire and EMS departments. Our story covers it.

What's next

The Audit and Finance Committee meets at 9:30 a.m. Wednesday, Nov. 18, at City Hall. Mayor Kirk Watson chairs it. Audit briefings are informational, and no vote is posted. The report is marked as a draft until it is presented.