On My Block · Austin Politics

Public safetyAudits

Police, fire and EMS spent $75 million on overtime while sworn staff did desk work civilians could do, audit says

A draft City Auditor report finds sworn officers, firefighters and medics handling records requests, recruiting and range duty. Labor contracts and state law limit how much can change soon.

Austin's police, fire and EMS departments are short hundreds of sworn employees and spent more than $75 million on overtime last year. Yet some sworn staff still do administrative work, from answering public records requests to running the police firing range, that a civilian could do for less. That's the finding of a draft City Auditor report posted for the City Council's Audit and Finance Committee on Wednesday, Nov. 18.

The auditors also found the quick savings are limited. State civil service law and the city's labor contracts restrict which jobs civilians can hold, so the bigger changes would have to come through future contract talks.

The numbers

Sworn vacancies as of September 2026:

  • Austin Police: 350
  • Austin-Travis County EMS: 134
  • Austin Fire: 80

Overtime the departments reported for the 2026 budget year:

  • Police: $36,342,357
  • Fire: $21,008,371
  • EMS: $18,143,030

The three departments employ more than 3,800 sworn staff and more than 700 civilians. A sworn employee's average salary runs about $19,000 more than a civilian's, the report says. Police lost both sworn and civilian positions between the 2019 and 2026 budgets, while fire and EMS added both.

Where civilians could step in

The auditors interviewed staff in all three departments:

  • EMS: Sworn medics have spent hours on public information requests. Civilians could also help move vehicles between stations, handle maintenance scheduling, run injury prevention outreach and assist trainers.
  • Police: Civilians could handle recruiting outreach and background checks, IT support, care of the mounted patrol's horses, wrecker enforcement and running the training academy's firing range, which sworn officers now manage on top of other duties. The report says the department has yet to carry out some civilian staffing recommendations from a 2024 consultant study, though it did move sworn staff to patrol.
  • Fire: Auditors found no clear tasks civilians could take over today without changes to the firefighters' contract, because of limits in Chapter 143 of the Texas Local Government Code and the agreement itself.

The report also suggests hiring retired sworn employees into civilian jobs, as some other Texas cities have done. Departments told auditors sworn experience can be valuable in some support roles, and that sworn staff are easier to reassign in a pinch.

What the departments said

All three chiefs and the city's chief labor relations officer agreed with the recommendations. Each department will draw up a list of jobs that could go to civilians, update it every year and send it to the Labor Relations Office to use in future bargaining. The final step is tied to renewal of each department's next labor agreement.

What our records add

Overtime has been on the table all year. At an Aug. 3 Public Safety Committee meeting, Police Chief Lisa Davis said commanders were now being asked "Who is using your overtime?" Austin Fire's chief of staff said the department's overtime budget was $10.2 million and it was already about 45% over, with spending expected to land closer to $21 million. The audit's fire figure, $21 million, matches that estimate.

The fire contract is new. The council approved a four-year collective bargaining agreement with the Austin Firefighters Association 11-0 in December 2025. Since the auditors found no fire tasks to civilianize under that contract, most changes there would wait for the next one.

Same meeting, second audit. The committee will also hear a credit card audit that found Austin issues far more cards than peer cities. Our story covers it.

What's next

The Audit and Finance Committee meets at 9:30 a.m. Wednesday, Nov. 18, at City Hall. The audit is a briefing, and no vote is posted. The council sets each department's number of sworn positions by ordinance, usually with the budget.