On My Block · Austin Politics

City HallSocial services

About 83% of Austin's social services deals will be grants, not contracts. Council members want to know what that means for results

Procurement staff told the Audit and Finance Committee the change recognizes what the agreements already are. The mayor said grants will still have to perform. Two public surveys close Dec. 13, and staff plan recommendations in January.

City staff took the "social services reset" to two council committees Wednesday, Nov. 18. The presentation was the one we described last week. The new information came from council members' questions at the Audit and Finance Committee, according to the transcript. The Economic Opportunity Committee heard the same briefing later that day and asked no questions.

Grants versus contracts

The reset splits the city's agreements with nonprofits into contracts, for services the city must provide, and grants, for services it chooses to fund.

Council Member Vanessa Fuentes asked how many fall in each group. James Scarborough of Austin Financial Services said he did not have an exact figure, but "roughly 83% of them are going forward as grant agreements and 17 as contracts." That could change if management decides to move some to contracts, he said.

How do other cities do it? "Most cities just label them as contracts," Scarborough said. The state has a separate legal basis for its grant agreements, but local governments do not, he said, so Austin is modeling its own rules on the state's. "When you evaluate a grant ... as a contract and you apply contract expectations to it, it doesn't compare well," he said.

Fuentes asked how that fits the council's push for outcomes. Scarborough said grants will tie performance to whether the grant continues, to incentive payments and to whether a provider can compete for future grants. "There will be a consequence for low or no performance and an incentive for positive and strong performance," he said.

'A square peg in a round hole'

Mayor Kirk Watson, who chairs the committee, said he worried people were not clear on the purpose, and asked staff to confirm the switch is not being made "because it's easier then to show performance." Scarborough said the agreements already "refer to themselves within the text of the agreement itself as grants."

"We were putting a square peg in a round hole," Watson said. "Just because you get a grant doesn't mean you don't have to perform."

Specialized providers

Council Member Marc Duchen asked how the two surveys will shape contracts and metrics, and how the city would judge a service area it has not funded before. Staff said they would look to national outcomes and best practices and collect baseline data first. Duchen said some providers work on "very specific issues" and asked that the city find a way "to calibrate how to start to evaluate those contracts."

Surveys and dates

Assistant City Manager Stephanie Hayden-Howard said two surveys, one for current, former and would-be providers and one for residents and people with lived experience, opened Nov. 13 and close Dec. 13, in eight languages, with fliers at libraries and recreation centers. She told the committee the feedback would inform recommendations "that we're going to share in January."

The timeline staff presented:

  • Through January 2027: define issue areas, services, agreement structures and funding levels.
  • Through February 2027: policy questions, such as overhead rates and pay-for-performance, go to this committee, the Economic Opportunity and Public Health committees, then the full council.
  • Starting January 2027: contract and grant solicitations are written and issued.
  • July 2027: providers start getting notices about new agreements.
  • October 2027: new agreements take effect with the 2028 budget year.

The city's portfolio is about $101 million, as we reported in October. The committees took no votes on the reset.

Support Austin Politics

Keep Austin Politics free for everyone

Austin Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime