On My Block · Austin Politics

City HallAudits

At the audit committee: finance staff promise yearly credit card reviews, and APD says state law keeps civilians from writing crash reports

Council members pressed for follow-up on two audits Wednesday. Police said two civilian community service officers are towing cars but cannot handle crashes, and the mayor said he will take the issue to a statewide mayors' group.

Two audits we wrote about last week went before the City Council's Audit and Finance Committee on Wednesday, Nov. 18. Here is what council members asked and what staff committed to, according to the meeting transcript. Mayor Kirk Watson chairs the committee.

Credit cards

The audit found Austin had 1,571 individual city credit cards and about $45 million in spending in the 2025 budget year, more than any of five other big Texas cities. Lead auditor Ashley Rodriguez told the committee that Austin's count is "nearly double" Houston's 867, and stressed that the audit "is not to say that we should cut cards dramatically."

James Scarborough of Austin Financial Services said his office was "relieved that such an important program, for the most part, operates well." He said it would, in the coming budget year:

  • review every card annually, with usage thresholds to flag cards with little or no activity;
  • add mandatory yearly refresher training for cardholders, approvers and reviewers;
  • keep eliminating automatic approvals and have departments attest each year that their monitoring works; and
  • analyze card spending yearly for purchases that should go through city contracts.

Scarborough said cards are for purchases under $3,000, and that his office "lead[s] by example" by removing cards from its non-supervisory staff, "close to 40 cards." Council Member Vanessa Fuentes asked for memos as each step is finished. Another council member asked what would happen if the city sharply limited cards, and asked for next year's review to be about as thorough as the audit.

Watson asked when Austin's numbers diverged from other cities'. A staff member said there is "likely going to be a bend in that curve right around covid," and Scarborough said the office would look at past volumes.

Civilians in public safety

The second audit found police, fire and EMS spent more than $75 million on overtime last year while some sworn staff did work a civilian could do, but that state law and labor contracts limit the quick gains. Audit manager Tyler Myers said the report is "not recommending reductions to authorized sworn staffing levels."

Mayor Pro Tem José "Chito" Vela, noting that public safety is about two-thirds of the general fund, asked about using non-officers for minor car crashes. APD Chief of Staff Lee Rogers said a pilot that began in April has two temporary community service officers who handle tagged vehicles and the vehicle abatement program, but "we haven't been able to utilize them in the crash response role," because state law requires a certified peace officer to complete the crash report filed with the state. APD described the community service officer idea to the council's Public Safety Committee in April.

A fire department official said state law requires certified firefighters for much of the fire prevention work, that about half of that section is already civilian, and that going further would require changes to the firefighters' contract.

A council member who said the topic had been a "key interest" for a couple of years cited false burglar alarms, which the member said are APD's second most common call and over 95% false, as another place to be "more creative."

Fuentes said a bill filed in the last legislative session would have let civilians in a police agency complete crash reports, and suggested adding the idea to the city's legislative agenda. Watson said he now chairs a Texas mayors' coalition, which is putting together a "Texas cities compact" built on "authority," "tools" and "resources," and that he would raise the issue there.

The assistant city manager over public safety said there are "opportunities that we can still explore," such as having community service officers direct traffic at a crash while one officer does the paperwork. Fuentes asked for specific options at the committee's next meeting.

Next year's committee

The committee approved its 2027 work plan. Watson said its January meeting, set to include the first report from the outside review of city operations, would instead be held as a full council work session, because committee assignments for the new council will not yet be made.

Management agreed with all four civilian staffing recommendations, the auditors said.

Support Austin Politics

Keep Austin Politics free for everyone

Austin Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime